Why can’t I stay within my budget?

Why can’t we stay within our budget? We keep getting surprises!  Why?

When I hear this question, the first thing I try to help my clients understand is that if they’re “budgeting” they’re always going to have “surprises.”  That’s because a budget is based on the idea of splitting up income into strict categories of spending and hoping you don’t need to go beyond any of those categories (because if you do, obviously you’ll be out of the allocated money and go over your budget, i.e have spending surprises). Read More

Should I Buy My Teen a Car?

“Should I buy my teenager a car? I can’t afford it but I feel like it’s expected.”

As I’m coaching clients, I often get questions like this.  Such questions come up because as people begin to work with the Spending Plan, they realize that a lot of things they did in the past without thinking they really can’t do anymore…they need to ask themselves some good hard questions first.

I always advise them that it’s a matter of balance.  If they can afford it, which is questionable unless the Spending Plan proves it, then that leaves the question of ownership, the insurance, impact on school work, etc.

I have an associate whose 16-year-old daughter ran into a woman on a horse, leaving the woman permanently disabled.  The associate’s total financial circumstances and emotions are totally up in the air.  For sure now, the other side is coming after them for everything they have.  In other words, the ownership of the car, the insurance status, and other factors could have been structured differently such that the financial consequences of the accident would have been more limited.

“Affordability” is not limited to the cost of the car. You need to ask yourself if you and your child can really afford this decision.  That goes for other things you feel you need to buy your children as well.  Ask yourself:  Can I really afford this?  The only way you’ll know is to begin by getting spending in balance using a Spending Plan.  There really is no other way, even if you want to let your child talk you into thinking otherwise.

If you don’t know what a Spending Plan is (P.S. it’s not a budget), I urge you to find out:  www.mymoneyplan.net or call me:  (888) 292-1099.

Abandon the “Budget” Mentality

Most everyone has been taught that the way to control spending is to write out a budget (which determines a set amount that can be spent based on how much money comes in each paycheck) and then stick to that budget.

But most people hate to budget because budgets simply doesn’t work — and let’s face it, they aren’t any fun!  Budgeting doesn’t account for the fact that it’s virtually impossible to limit spending to ONLY the amount that comes home each month.  For that reason, budgets destine people for failure even before they get started on trying to keep one.

There’s a better way to control spending using the 3-pronged approach. 
Just as a three-legged stool needs all of its legs to stand, a good spending system that will actually help you get in control requires three crucial elements, all of which must be present and working at the same time to be effective:

Prong 1: Spending Plan.  First, plan (or forecast) how you want and need to spend money within prescribed categories; you determine these spending categories based on how you have spent money in the past.

Prong 2:  Tracking.   Second, track how you actually spend your money within these categories.

Prong 3: Compare.   Third, compare tracked spending monthly with your original plan to see what’s actually left over based on your income, then adjust spending priorities for the next month so that you can balance your income with your spending and still have the things you want without spending more than you have.

Using this three-pronged tracking approach allows the following:

  • Lets you “prove your priorities” to yourself as your needs and wants change.
  • Helps you remain in control when unforeseen problems occur, or when you want to spend on impulse.
  • Best of all, it allows you to spend while still watching your bank account grow.

Different from Budgeting.  This spending approach is much different than traditional “budgeting” methods because it doesn’t force you to focus on what you can’t have. Instead, making a spending plan, tracking your spending according to that plan, and then comparing that spending monthly with available income gives you all the following benefits:

  • Lets you feel free to spend in the areas of your life to which you have given the highest priority.
  • Helps you track how your spending will affect your daily needs, emotional wants, and long-term security
  • Rather than showing you what you have done after the fact, when it may be too late (as budgeting does), a plan and tracking that plan lets you know what you have left to spend after each expenditure.

Budgets are static and don’t account for life “coming at you” and for the need to be flexible in the way that you spend.  But planning and tracking allow you to alter your spending as needed and make different choices going forward so you can remain in control while still giving you the freedom to spend money in areas that you deem important.

A budget dictates what areas to cut, but tracking indicates the most meaningful areas for you and your family in which you want to spend.  Budgets are depressing and difficult to force oneself to do, but planning, tracking, and comparing are fun and encouraging when they are done with specific goals and dreams for now and the future in mind.

What Would Happen If You Died Tonight?

Alan’s latest article on this very compelling question is featured on the Vistage.com Executive Street blog:  http://blog.vistage.com/finance/what-would-happen-if-you-died-tonight/.  This is a great chance to see how to:

  1. Kill yourself on paper.
  2. Find out where the gaps are in your estate planning.
  3. Determine if you are leaving minor children in heartbreaking situations should both you and your spouse die together.

 

What you don’t know is hurting you.  Learn more by reading Alan’s latest advice:  http://blog.vistage.com/finance/what-would-happen-if-you-died-tonight/.

Materialism Kills Marriages

An October 2011 research report published by Brigham Young University and William Paterson University shows that materialism kills marriages.

A survey of 1,700 married couples found that materialism, especially when it shows up in both partners, creates unstable marriages, ineffective communication, and other emotional factors that can affect how happy couples are within their marriage.

We  have found in years of mentoring couples that there really is no cure for materialism until couples take a good, hard look at their emotions surrounding money and how it’s spent.  The best way to face emotions about money is through the weekly Money Huddle and by creating a spending plan together.

Rate yourself. On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being least materialistic, how do you think your marriage rates?  If you score high, what are you doing to make sure your marriage is stable?

Comments on what the Money Huddle has done for you are welcome here.